A British woman used more than £1 million of her elderly mother’s money for holidays, cars, shopping and a lavish wedding; High Court ordered her to hand back £2.6 million after a bitter inheritance battle | World News

A British woman used more than £1 million of her elderly mother's money for holidays, cars, shopping and a lavish wedding; High Court ordered her to hand back £2.6 million after a bitter inheritance battle
Sandra Thomas and her husband, Philip Thomas, outside court ( Image: Champion News/ Independent)

A British woman who used more than £1 million of her elderly mother’s money to fund holidays, luxury shopping, cars and family weddings has been ordered to return the money, along with three properties worth approximately £1.6 million, following a bitter inheritance dispute with her brother. Sandra Thomas, 65, and her husband, Philip Thomas, were found to have used Jeanne MacDougall’s bank accounts as their own while managing her finances under a lasting power of attorney. The High Court ruled that the couple had breached their legal responsibilities and unduly influenced Jeanne into transferring properties to them. However, the judge also upheld Jeanne’s final will, which largely favoured her daughter and son-in-law.

Couple spent mother’s fortune on holidays, cars and lavish weddings

According to the court proceedings, Sandra and Philip used Jeanne’s money to pay for a range of personal and family expenses, including holidays, new cars, shopping trips and meals at the prestigious London restaurant The Ivy.The spending also included their daughter’s wedding at the five-star Savoy hotel, another family wedding, college fees for their children and numerous cash withdrawals.The judge, Nicola Rushton KC, said the total amount spent through Jeanne’s accounts exceeded £1 million, although she did not calculate the precise figure. She noted a pattern in which properties were sold, the proceeds deposited into Jeanne’s bank accounts and the money subsequently used to meet the couple’s expenses.“There was a clear cycle of emptying Jeanne’s bank accounts, realising an asset to generate more cash, and then repeating the process again,” the judge said.She added that the couple had given no thought to how Jeanne’s future care would be funded and that she had virtually no cash left when she died in 2020.

Three properties worth £1.6 million transferred to couple

The financial dispute also involved three properties that Sandra and Philip had obtained from Jeanne during her lifetime.These included a holiday home in Peacehaven, East Sussex, valued at approximately £400,000, and two flats in Ealing, west London, worth around £1.2 million combined.The judge found that the transfers resulted from undue influence by the couple over Jeanne.In the case of the Peacehaven property, the court heard that Sandra and Philip had justified the transfer by suggesting that Gary already had a holiday home in Cyprus and had received enough from the family business.However, the judge concluded that these arguments were likely used by the couple to persuade Jeanne to transfer the property.She said the transaction marked the beginning of a pattern in which decisions increasingly favoured Sandra, Philip and their family over Gary and his family.The same finding of undue influence applied to the transfers of the two Ealing flats.

Brother challenged mother’s final will over dementia concerns

The inheritance dispute was brought by Jeanne’s son, Gary MacDougall, 70, who argued that his mother had not been mentally capable of making her final will in 2011.He claimed that Jeanne, who suffered from Alzheimer’s disease, had lost much of her independence and did not properly understand the consequences of changing her will.Gary also argued that his parents had always intended their two children to receive broadly equal financial treatment and inheritance.Under Jeanne’s 2008 will, properties in Avenue Crescent and Berrymead Gardens were allocated to Gary and his family, while Sandra and Philip were to receive properties in Stuart Road and Avenue Gardens. Sandra was also entitled to most of the money in Jeanne’s bank accounts.However, a revised will made in 2011 left all four properties to Sandra and Philip, while Sandra continued to receive the majority of her mother’s savings. Gary and Sandra were to share the remaining estate.Gary challenged the revised arrangement, arguing that his mother had been suffering from dementia when she signed the document and that her decision did not reflect the family’s earlier understanding.

Judge upheld will despite finding financial misconduct

In a significant part of the ruling, Judge Rushton rejected Gary’s challenge to the 2011 will, concluding that Jeanne had the necessary mental capacity to make it and had not been unduly influenced into changing its terms.The judge acknowledged that Jeanne was genuinely grateful to Sandra and Philip for providing her with a home and supporting her in her later years. She said it was understandable that Jeanne wanted to reward them.However, this did not excuse the couple’s conduct in managing her finances.Sandra and Philip’s barrister, Alexander Learmonth KC, had accepted that they overstepped their responsibilities under the lasting power of attorney by spending Jeanne’s money on themselves and their family.Their defence was that they believed the spending was effectively an advance on their inheritance, as Sandra was already expected to receive most of her mother’s cash under both wills. They also argued that they believed they were acting in accordance with Jeanne’s wishes and had not received proper advice about their responsibilities.The judge rejected these explanations, stating that ignorance of their duties was not a defence. She described the misconduct as deliberate and driven by greed.

Couple ordered to restore money and properties to mother’s estate

Following the ruling, Sandra and Philip were required to return the three properties or their value to Jeanne’s estate and account for the money they had spent from her bank accounts.The three properties were worth approximately £1.6 million, while the money spent through the accounts exceeded £1 million, bringing the combined amount involved to around £2.6 million.The exact amount of compensation payable for the money taken was still to be calculated through a further accounting process.The recovered assets and compensation will increase the value of the estate’s remaining assets, half of which will go to Gary under the terms of the upheld will.Despite the ruling, Sandra and Philip are still expected to receive a substantial inheritance under the 2011 will. The judge’s decision therefore preserved Jeanne’s final testamentary wishes while requiring the couple to restore assets that had been improperly obtained or spent during her lifetime.

Leave a Comment