No fraud, no undertaking to repay: Uttarakhand HC refuses to allow recovery of Rs 23 lakh from retired constable’s gratuity, upholds tribunal order and gives authorities 10 weeks to release his dues | Dehradun News

No fraud, no undertaking to repay: Uttarakhand HC refuses to allow recovery of Rs 23 lakh from retired constable's gratuity, upholds tribunal order and gives authorities 10 weeks to release his dues
Uttarakhand HC protects retired constable from Rs 23 lakh gratuity recovery (Representative image generated using AI)

DEHRADUN: Uttarakhand high court has declined to interfere with a Public Services Tribunal ruling that had set aside the recovery of Rs 23,08,264 from the gratuity payable to retired constable Gokulanand Pathak.A division bench of Acting Chief Justice Manoj Kumar Tiwari and Justice Subhash Upadhyay disposed of the state’s petition while permitting the competent authority to refix Pathak’s pay and pension and directing it to release all his retiral dues within 10 weeks.The state and others had challenged the Tribunal’s December 20, 2024, judgment, which had allowed Pathak’s claim petition, quashed the June 1, 2023, order directing recovery of Rs 23,08,264 from his gratuity, and directed the authorities to release his pension and other retiral dues within 60 days.Before the HC, the state submitted that 19 punishments had been imposed on Pathak between 1997 and 2003. It argued that he was aware that he was not entitled to the salary amount received by him but had failed to inform the departmental authorities about the excess payment.On this basis, the state contended that he was equally responsible for receiving the excess amount and that the recovery was justified.The court noted that the Tribunal had considered the matter in detail and relied on the Supreme Court judgment in State of Punjab vs Rafiq Masih (White Washer) & others. It also recorded that, before the Tribunal, the state itself had submitted that the controversy was covered by the Supreme Court’s decision in the Rafiq Masih case.The bench, on November 17, observed that it was not the state’s case that Pathak had committed fraud or played any role in securing the excess payment.Nor had it been pleaded that he had given any undertaking to refund the amount if he was found ineligible. In the absence of such pleadings, the court said there was “hardly any scope for interference” with the Tribunal’s view.Pathak stated that he did not wish to contest the refixation of his pay. His counsel also submitted that he had no objection to the refixation of his pension based on the revised pay.The HC accordingly permitted the authorities to refix his pay and pension and directed them to release his retiral dues within 10 weeks.

Leave a Comment