CHANDIGARH: A 47-year-old assistant professor who underwent a heart transplant costing Rs 27.97 lakh was reimbursed only around Rs 10 lakh under government medical rules, prompting him to fight his case before the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) himself. The tribunal has now directed the Chandigarh Administration and other authorities to reimburse his full medical expenditure.Dr Sanjeev Kumar, an Assistant Professor of Defence and Strategic Studies at Post Graduate Government College, Sector 11, Chandigarh, had approached the tribunal after a substantial portion of his medical reimbursement claim remained unpaid despite his life-threatening condition and emergency treatment.The CAT Chandigarh Bench held that the authorities could not restrict reimbursement to prescribed package rates when the treatment was necessitated by a medical emergency and specialised facilities were unavailable at government hospitals in Chandigarh.Dr Kumar, who appeared in person, had initially submitted a claim of Rs 27.97 lakh towards his heart transplant and related medical expenses. The authorities sanctioned Rs 8.82 lakh in February 2023 and another Rs 1.20 lakh in September 2025, leaving a substantial portion of the claim unpaid.The Chandigarh Administration and education authorities argued that reimbursement was governed by the Punjab Medical Attendance Rules, 1940, and a Punjab government notification dated February 13, 1995. Under these provisions, they contended, employees opting for treatment at private hospitals were entitled to reimbursement only at prescribed rates.Disputing this, Dr Kumar argued that the reduction in his verified medical expenses had been made without consultation with the requisite Medical Board or Committee of Technical Experts.The tribunal, comprising Member (Judicial) Suresh Kumar Batra and Member (Administrative) Anjali Bhawra, observed that his treatment was undertaken in a grave and potentially life-threatening situation, not out of convenience or personal preference.“The question is not whether reimbursement procedures may generally be prescribed, but whether those procedures can be applied mechanically to deny a substantial part of the expenditure incurred on emergent treatment, that was urgently required to save the applicant’s life,” it observed.“The extra-ordinary situation requires extraordinary treatment,” the tribunal added.Dr Kumar was diagnosed with advanced coronary artery disease on September 14, 2019, and underwent implantation of an Automated Implantable Cardioverter Defibrillator (AICD) on September 29, 2021.His condition deteriorated in April 2022 when he suffered recurrent ventricular tachycardia and heart failure, requiring emergency hospitalisation at Fortis Hospital, Mohali.Following another medical emergency on May 25, 2022, doctors recommended a heart transplant on July 2. He was admitted to MGM Healthcare, Chennai, on August 7, 2022, and underwent the transplant on August 10.The professor had also sought medical leave and reimbursement for the transplant and post-operative treatment, but his leave requests were rejected while his reimbursement claim remained partly unpaid.The tribunal directed the authorities to reimburse the full actual expenditure incurred on the transplant and related treatment, subject to verification of the genuineness of bills and treatment records. The Rs 8.82 lakh and Rs 1.20 lakh already sanctioned or disbursed will be adjusted against the total verified expenditure.