Between the dead and the alive

Between the dead and the alive
(AI Image) The absoluteness of death is something we like to resist.

There is nothing deader than dead. As Joseph Heller so successfully puts it in Catch-22, “Clewinger was dead. That was the flaw in his philosophy?” You cannot nuance your way out of that sentence.The absoluteness of death is something we like to resist. Immortality is among the oldest of human desires. Less ambitiously, but just as significantly, there is the drive towards longevity, so much in evidence today. Tech bros most famously spend enormous time and effort ensuring that their precious beings are preserved for the benefit of the rest of us for as long as possible. Hyperbaric chambers, cold plunging, infrared saunas, red-light therapy and a few dozen supplements every day are all part of the regime.But death is cruelly indifferent to our sense of our own specialness. The atoms that make us up go on, eventually, to become other things. We experience the decay of our bodies as something significant, but in the larger scheme, all that happens is that matter changes shape and form.What exactly do we mean when we say that something is alive? We may be better served by asking not about what living things are but what they do. They take in nourishment from the outside world to keep themselves going and expel what they don’t need. They are continually repairing and renewing themselves. Living things resist for a while the tug of disorder, although eventually it’s a losing battle. A living thing is not merely an object but a process. When that process stops, it dies.The idea that living beings are processes rather than things is both obvious and counterintuitive, if such a thing is possible. We are forms; we are made up of substance, as is all life, and to think of ourselves as flows rather than stocks is not easy.Part of the reason is that we need to make no conscious effort to keep the processes of life going. We breathe, our hearts beat, our food gets digested all by itself. We don’t carry the burden of continuity. Had we been responsible for these, we would have had time for little else. The unconscious nature of staying alive makes it feel that life is the default state.The shock of seeing a lifeless body comes from the fact that, at one level, the object looks intact. All of what we thought of as ourselves looks like it hits us. The body now no apparent indication of what was about to happen; some vital process just stopped. The shock of people dying before their time reveals our implicit mental model of life.That is because death is absolute in a way decay is not. An object can be damaged bit by bit; we get that. But the process of being alive is different. When it finally stops, there is no restarting it. We can put someone in an induced coma, but that is merely dimming the lights, not extinguishing them. And for those who freeze their bodies and hope for future technology to bring them back to their original selves, so far, that’s just a hope. And I am not dying to find out how that works out.The truth is that when the process finally ends, we stop existing. There is no threshold to cross, no ‘other side’. The problem is, even if we are not merely objects, we need to experience ourselves as enduring beings. To experience ourselves as we actually are, an intricate web of processes constantly adjusting to the world around us to keep us alive, would be deeply disorienting. A stable self is what lets us love someone over time and feel responsible for what we do, and for that we have to feel like the same person from one day to the next.A switch has been flipped, and our entire entity has, for all practical purposes, disappeared. That we are patterns made possible by a process calls for us to look beyond the manner in which we experience ourselves.Since death typically happens with age, when we see the gradual signs of the body withering, it seems as if it is a failure of the physical self. Bit by bit, the body becomes decrepit and loses strength till one day it gives up. Decay and deterioration are things we understand. All physical objects degrade with time, and so does our body.It is when a fit young person dies at a gym while working out that the shock hits us. The body now no apparent indication of what was about to happen; some vital process just stopped. The shock of people dying before their time reveals our implicit mental model of life.That is because death is absolute in a way decay is not. An object can be damaged bit by bit; we get that. But the process of being alive is different. When it finally stops, there is no restarting it. We can put someone in an induced coma, but that is merely dimming the lights, not extinguishing them. And for those who freeze their bodies and hope for future technology to bring them back to their original selves, so far, that’s just a hope. And I am not dying to find out how that works out.The truth is that when the process finally ends, we stop existing. There is no threshold to cross, no ‘other side’. The problem is, even if we are not merely objects, we need to experience ourselves as enduring beings. To experience ourselves as we actually are, an intricate web of processes constantly adjusting to the world around us to keep us alive, would be deeply disorienting. A stable self is what lets us love someone over time and feel responsible for what we do, and for that we have to feel like the same person from one day to the next.A switch has been flipped, and our entire entity has, for all practical purposes, disappeared. That we are patterns made possible by a process calls for us to look beyond the manner in which we experience ourselves.Another way to think about life is as a flame, and, in fact, life itself can be thought of as an “akhand diya”, a lamp that is never extinguished. A flame lights another, and while individual flames die out, the fire never goes out. Or think of the jamun of dahi, where the living cultures of the curd travel from one bowl to another, from one home to another, one century to another. But the flame that goes out does not come back.To come back to where we started, there is nothing deader than dead. No mysterious substance has been subtracted. The matter that made up the body remains. None of it, by itself, was the life. The river stopped flowing. That’s all.


Disclaimer
: Views expressed above are the author’s own.

Leave a Comment